Showing posts with label journey to essential oils. Show all posts
Showing posts with label journey to essential oils. Show all posts

Sunday, June 8, 2014

{Essential Oils} How I Saved Money by Switching To.....

Alrighty, let's dig into this last essential oil post, shall we?


You all have been SO patient as I've outlined all of my research and guinea pig testing (hi, family!) where essential oils are concerned. If you are just jumping into this series, I would love for you to take a second to go back to the previous posts and catch up on where we've been:
Now that we are all on the same page, I have a confession to make.

I wasn't overly thrilled when I found out what the best, most effective, most affordable essential oil company was.

Oh, I know that sounds backwards. Wouldn't I be thrilled to have finally landed on the company that we were going to use. Well....

Here's my fear. I'm a blogger, right? I help support my family with this blog. It's great! But I never, and I mean NEVER post things that I can't get behind 100%. I've turned down more campaigns than I can count because either they weren't relative to me/you or I just couldn't ethically endorse them. As a blogger, my reputation is really all I have in this space. If that is gone...POOF...you might as well move on to another blog.

And that's why I started to get a bit nervous when it became readily apparent which brand of oils were the best. I kept thinking to myself, "My readers will never believe that this is unbiased if I tell them who really won the essential oil battle at our house!"

Gosh, darn it.

But I opened this can of worms, so I guess I best cough up the answer. Just know that as we work through this post, this truly IS the brand that I believe is best. Furthermore, I had actually planned a long post about a different essential oil company that I was going to pair with a giveaway for some of their oils, but 
I had to scrap the whole thing when their oils did nothing to support my immune system. Not only was it frustrating, it would have been unethical for me to continue with that post after the results I experienced.

So all I ask is that you don't discount what I'm saying or leave until you read the WHOLE post, okay? I mean, you've read this far. You might as well read all of my reasoning and the facts behind my choice.
We chose to use Young Living Essential Oils.

They are hands down the best, most effective, and most affordable essential oil company. And I want to walk you through exactly how it fits my list of requirements.
How are Young Living Essential Oils the Best:
  • They are the ONLY company that owns their own farms. Not only that, but they own more than 10,000 acres on six different continents so that they can grow plants in their natural habitats. Plus, they know when to harvest (some plants can only be harvested in a two hour time frame in the mornings in order to maintain their therapeutic value) and have distilleries right on the land.
  • They plant on fields that have been untouched by chemicals and follow those plants from seeds all the way to the bottles. "Organic" oils can legally come from GMO seeds, but Young Living takes that a step further by avoiding even those. If it's possible to be more than organic, Young Living has figured out how to do it.
  • They have 20 years of experience, and have set the international standard for essential oils.
  • They are the ones who invented the stringent tests that essential oil companies use. Most companies don't do all of the tests because they can be pricey, but Young Living conducts them all. On every batch of oil. Every time.
  • They only bottle and sell approximately 30% of the essential oils that they distill. The remaining 70% are sold off to other essential oil and soap companies as fragrance oils because they don't meet the extremely high quality control that Young Living has in place.
  • They have the most single oils and blends available. And they are all organic!
  • They have wholesale pricing available when you buy a membership (like Costco or Sam's Club!)

How are Young Living Essential Oils the Most Effective:

Not all oils are created equal!

The Essential Oils Pocket Reference, Fifth Edition has a section that talks about real lavender oil vs. lavandin (a hybrid) which is often cut with the synthetic linalyl acetate. The adulterated hybrid smells the same and is often sold AS lavender but is definitely not the same. However, companies can produce this synthetic adulterated substance in much larger quantities for a lower cost, so that is often what is passed off for the real thing, "For every kilogram of pure essential oil that is produced, it is estimated that there are between 10 and 100 kilograms of synthetic oil created (p. 22)."

On top of that, The Chemistry of Essential Oils Made Simple says, "A common practice is to take a decent grade of essential oil and dilute it 90% to 95% with an odorless, colorless solvent (usually an inexpensive petrochemical) so that what was a pound of good oil becomes ten or twenty pounds of diluted oils to be sold as if it were the original substance. thus multiplying the profit. Such diluted oils often carry labels saying "Genuine" or "100% pure," which is allowed by the U.S. FDA....Mysteriously, for every pound of frankincense distilled in the world, more than a dozen pounds are eventually sold (p. 12)."

Something's not right here.

Remember how last time we talked about how bottles of essential oil are only required to have 5% of the oil be actually pure? Yeah, what companies are really saying is that the 5% is the 100% pure part of the oil. Sneaky, sneaky! It makes me nervous, and I end up feeling a little bit ripped off when I read that. If I buy a $10 bottle of essential oil from the wrong company, I may actually be buying only $0.50 worth of pure oil and $9.50 worth of filler and synthetic substances. Whoa, not cool!

So the integrity of the oil in the bottle is really important! 5% worth of pure oil is not going to have the same effect as 100% (true, 100%) pure oil. The oils work faster, you need less, and you don't spend as much with a true 100% pure bottle of essential oil.

You must trust the company that you are buying from, and Young Living has proven over and over that they are trustworthy. I don't worry about synthetic substances or diluted bottles with their company.
How are Young Living Essential Oils the Most Affordable:

There are cheaper essential oil companies for sure! There is no denying that. But if they don't work, then the oils are a waste of money. That's just logical! The cheaper companies have to be as or more effective than Young Living to even be considered. Or I might as well wallpaper my bathroom with dollar bills, you know what I mean?

But I can actually do one better than just telling you that they are affordable. I can show you! Take a deep breath, because you are about to read through a slew of numbers!

I like cold, hard facts. So I want to show you how I saved money by switching from the other, cheaper essential oil companies to Young Living. Remember that awful 5 weeks of absolutely bottomed out immune system stuff that I had to deal with earlier this year? If you don't, then please stop right now and go read that post so that you know what I'm talking about. It's really important to have the back story on this.

After unsuccessfully trying to use essential oils to support my body’s systems for all of those weeks, I was ready to throw them all in a box and set them out on the curb. But I decided to give it one last try. I switched back to Young Living. I figured that I really had nothing to lose at that point.

I actually kept track, drop for drop, exactly which and how much oil I used while trying to find that happy wellness plateau that I knew existed out there somewhere. I also went back and added up what we paid to treat my 2nd round of bronchitis with prescriptions, doctors' bills, and tests (which is the opposite of being well). Wellness is an investment. It doesn’t just happen. So my goal was to compare what I spent to maintain wellness vs. what I spent when I didn’t do anything but just live like a typical American.
The total cost was 5.5 hours of time spent waiting for medical attention + $57.87 on the 80/20 portion of our insurance plan. If we hadn't already maxed out our initial deductible (because we've been so sick this year!), then that number would have jumped to $274.15. For ONE round of bronchitis.

What this chart doesn't include is the cost of the over-the-counter meds and cheaper oils that I also used, and the follow-up doctor's appointment and repeat spirometry test and chest x-rays three weeks later to make sure that my lungs were clear. I couldn't fit all of that on the chart! So the number that you see on the chart is just PART of what I actually spent to fix the 2nd round of bronchitis. The number gets much higher when you include everything that I actually spent just for that one illness.

Again, as humans, we get sick. That’s just life. It’s not really something that can be avoided unless we live in a bubble. The idea here is to keep our wellness level in such great shape that we have very happy immune systems. Make sense?


After my very rough spring, I wanted to do everything I could to get immune system back on track. I was desperate! Since I had the essential oils, that's where I focused. I started by taking the cost of the bottle of oil (using my wholesale member prices) and dividing it by the number of drops in the bottle so that I would know exactly how many pennies worth I was rubbing, ingesting, and diffusing. We are on a budget over here, so cost is an extremely important factor in decisions we make. Here is what I used to start intensely focusing on my wellness:

My total? 5 days to feel awesome and $24.41 worth of oils.

$24.41 worth of Young Living oils!

And from that point on, I was 100% sold that Young Living has the Best, Most Effective, and Most Affordable oils.

SAVED money by switching back to Young Living. Not to mention a lot of miserableness and the weeks of downtime that come with completely ignoring y body!

But there was one more thing that I had to deal with. Like I said in my last essential oil post, I had an extremely bad experience with a previous multi-level marketing company. It's made me understandably skittish about getting too close to another one (Side note: I think most of the companies make GREAT products, but generally speaking, people in them can get burned). While I realize that some people aren't too concerned about that and just want to get started with essential oils, others want to take a more conservative approach to diving in. Totally understandable! There are two ways that you can try Young Living, which means that you can pick what makes you the most comfortable: 

1. If you want to try just 1 or 2 oils to see if you like them, you can set up a Retail Account and get only what you are the most interested in. No pressure to buy more. Just the chance to give the oils a try on your terms. In fact, if you set up a retail account through my link to order an oil and would like more info to accompany that oil, I'd be happy to send you a small booklet if you will reach out to me with your address. I would love to help you learn how to use that oil in your home and love the results! theishumquads "at" gmail.com

2. If you like the oils or want to start with the same Premium Starter Kit that I have (highly recommended!), then you can sign up for your own wholesale membership.Full disclosure: I get a commission if you use my membership number as a referral. However, I'm all about the research and education behind oils, so I will take that commission, turn around, and use it to buy and ship you a Wellness Resource Kit. The kit is not put out or created by Young Living, but it has things in it that have been helpful to me, and I think it will be helpful to you as well. It has a reference book that covers how to use the oils along with a few other items like a dropper bottle for carrier oils and a roll on bottle for easy application. I'll also add you to a really fantastic group for members that I'm in. They give real help in real time to real questions. It's been invaluable. If you want more info on a Young Living membership, my Wellness Resource Kit, or the private FaceBook group, you can jump over to this post. (I had to break it into a separate post because this one is too long!)

I care so much about you using the best, most effective, and most affordable oils, giving your family a leg up when it comes to wellness, and making sure that you have the research and education to use oils safely and effectively. Please understand that I'm not saying to abandon modern healthcare. I'm a big fan of what the medical community has done for my family, and I will gratefully use them again when necessary. Essential oils are simply part of an overall wellness lifestyle that keeps people feeling awesome! I only wish that I had found them years ago. 


*deep breath* Sheesh! Can I ramble or what? Are you still with me?

Finally, thanks for following along on my essential oil journey. I hope that you enjoyed reading my research and found it helpful. I'm going to continue researching and learning about these, so stay tuned for some fun things coming up, like, how to make your own all natural lip balm customized with your favorite essential oils! Meanwhile, please head over to the second part of this post for info about getting your own essential oils!

The information contained in these posts are for educational and entertainment purposes only. They are not meant to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or ailment. Please do your own research and make your own informed decisions when you are considering lifestyle and health changes. Particularly if you are pregnant, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult a doctor before starting anything new. Any links leaving this site are the opinion of the author of those sites and should be treated with the same caution as what you read here. This post may contain affiliate links. For more info, please see my disclaimer page.

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Essential Oils: Which Essential Oil Company is Best? (and reviews of five popular companies!)

Which essential oil company is best?
I've had several people email and ask me to just tell them which essential oil company I went with. Lol! I guess this series is taking awhile to get through, isn't it?

But I'm doing it this way on purpose. Not to torture you, I promise! I think too often people on the internet just tell you what you need to do, or think, or buy, or use without anything to back their statements up. I could totally do that, but that's not my style. When I am looking at something new for my family, I want to know the "why" behind what someone recommends or uses. It's important to me to understand the background and how they got there, because this is my family that we are talking about.

And I want the same thing for you.

You should get to know the why and the background and the research instead of just the punchline too. I love y'all, and love having you in the community here on A Beautiful Ruckus. I think you deserve to "be in the know," you know? So yes, it takes a little longer this way, but maybe you can avoid investing in several essential oil companies and using your family members as guinea pigs like I did.

Whether you want it or not, you really should have all of the info and not just go use a brand or method because I say so.

So today, we are going to look at brands. In my quest to find the BEST brand, the LEAST EXPENSIVE brand, and the MOST EFFECTIVE brand, I did a bunch of research and collected oils from five different companies. Man, this was not the cheap way to go about it, but in terms of making an informed decision, it was very effective!

First of all, there are TONS of essential oil companies on the internet. I thought there were like...six total or something. Not so much! There are so many, that I couldn't possibly try all of them and still have money leftover to eat. So I've noted why I chose the ones I did.

Almost every essential oil company claims that they are 100% pure. We can get into lots of definitions another time, BUT I want to make sure you understand the "100% pure" claim going into this post. Essential oils are really not regulated very much (or arguably, at all). Manufacturing regulations require a minimum of 5% pure oil inside the bottle to earn a 100% Therapeutic Grade label. How does that work? The 5% of the bottle that is 100% pure earns the labeling since that 5% is in and of itself completely pure. So a bottle that has 5% pure oil and 95% synthetic oil and/or carrier oil can still be labeled with the 100% pure claim. So each of these companies is claiming 100% pure oil, and the trick is to figure out just how much of the bottle is the real stuff that you want.

Is your head spinning yet? Stick with me!

My two main goals as I tried these oils were:
1.    I needed oils that are affordable. If I have to mortgage my house to buy oils, we have a problem. I needed something that I could afford to buy on a regular basis and use daily without freaking out about cost.
2.    I needed to find oils that work. I know that seems rather obvious, but I wanted to know how much of the essential oil usage effects were just in my head. I addressed that in my last post, but I quickly learned that not all oils work as effectively as others. Besides that, if I buy oils that don't work, no matter how cheap they are, that's makes them a waste of money. Which makes them unaffordable (see point 1).

***********************

So in no particular order, here are the pros and cons of the brands that I've tried:
(note: these photos do not represent all of my oils. I just grabbed random ones out of my box, and threw them on my front steps for quick photos.)

1. Bulk Apothecary
Which essential oil company is best?
Why did I try this company?
Well...I wanted the inexpensive, most effective essential oils out there. And Bulk Apothecary is cheap. The cheapest essential oil company that I came across. I figured it was worth a try.

Pros:
Man, they are SO cheap! Seriously, you can buy a ton of oils for just a few dollars! I like to compare prices on the three big oils that most people should have in their arsenal:


They also have a great selection of other items for soap, candle, beer, and wine making. If you are into making your own items like that, then it's a good one-stop-shop to pick up a lot of stuff at the same time.

If you put items in your basket and fill out your account info, they will send you a 5% off coupon in your email to get you to make your purchase. If you wait a few extra days, they will send you a 10% off coupon. That's as high as it goes though. :)

I asked a customer service rep how many essential oils they carry. She said, "more than 140 types of essential oils. A few are organic, but most are not."

Cons:

I was really disappointed to open my bottle of lime oil and see that it didn't have an orifice reducer. An orifice reducer is that little part that sits inside the top of the bottle to prevent the oil from coming out faster than a drop at a time. Just an FYI, it's impossible to pour just a single drop of oil out of an open bottle like that. I tried on several different occasions and finally gave up out of frustration. Does. Not. Work.

The oil felt really cheap. It was thin....and just felt weird. I wasn't impressed at all. Yeah, I get that I'm talking about the way that it felt and poured, but I don't find myself thinking, "Hmm! I could really go for some lime oil right now!" Sadness.

Shipping was expensive.

Most of their oils are not organic.

They are essential oil re-bottlers, meaning that, they don't distill their own oils. They simply buy them and rebottle them with their labels. Then they turn around and sell them.

I looked to see what others were saying about Bulk Apothecary to see if my thoughts were unfounded. They have extremely high ratings on their website which was one of the reasons that I wanted to try them. After checking reviews on 3rd party sites, I saw that people were complaining that they tried multiple times to leave negative reviews on the Bulk Apothecary website and they were never approved. It seems many others also felt that the oils were too cheap and not effective as they hoped. The general consensus was that these work best as fragrance oils, used to scent soap and candles, and not necessarily for therapeutic use. Honestly, I couldn't figure out how they were selling therapeutic essential oils at that price point in the first place, so that make sense to me.

2. Aura Cacia
Which essential oil company is best?
Why did I try this company?
I actually totally forgot that I even had an oil from this company until I started working on this post. In a moment of desperation, I picked up Eucalyptus last October to give it a try. I bought it from the health food section of the grocery store.

Pros:
Aura Cacia is highly accessible. Most health food stores and health markets inside grocery stores carry this brand.

You don't have to wait for it or pay to have it shipped to you.

They are priced on par with a lot of other mail order companies:
They come with a drop reducer orifice.



By my count, they have 89 single oils and 21 blends. A small portion of the single oils are organic.

Cons:
Well, I didn't feel that the oil worked well. I rubbed some on my chest with a carrier oil and it helped my coughing for about...four minutes. I tried for a couple of days, and even put some on my feet, but it just wasn't effective. I've since used it a couple of times by putting it over my sinuses for a stuffy nose. That seemed to work better than using it for coughing, but I found my experience with the oil to be frustrating.

Most of their oils are not organic.

They are oil rebottlers. They buy their oils already distilled and rebottle them with their marketing labels.

3. Mountain Rose Herbs
Which essential oil company is best?
Why did I try this company?
I'm a blogger, and I follow bloggers. This company is a very popular company for bloggers to recommend so it kept showing up in my research. Note: This company has an affiliate program. I imagine that is why some bloggers like to recommend them. I totally don't hold that against the bloggers because you have to afford posting free content on the internet somehow (blogging isn't free, guys!). But I wanted to know how many of their referrals were for business reasons and how many were because Mountain Rose Herbs really does offer the best essential oils out there.

Pros:
It's a very well recommended company!

Their prices are reasonable:


All of their oils come with those drop reducer orifices! Thank goodness!

As a blogger, they have an affiliate program that could help offset the money that I pay to afford a blog. BUT that doesn't really weigh in on whether or not the oils are the best out there. If they aren't good, I ethically can't recommend them. Plus, why would I take money in exchange for not giving my family the best?

They also offer a wide range of other products, most notably their extensive herb selection.

They offer 111 single oils, all of which are organic. They do not offer any blends.

Cons:

They seemed to have decent oils. I've used the ones I've bought and didn't get the cheap feel that I did from Bulk Apothecary. I also wasn't blown out of the water, but they are nice. I guess 'indifferent' was how I felt about them.

They are also essential oil rebottlers. They buy their oils, already distilled, and then rebottle, label, and sell them.

They do not offer any essential oil blends.
4. Plant Therapy
Which essential oil company is best?
Why did I try this company?
I was googling for essential oil companies, and this one popped up. I like the prices and the free shipping, so I thought that I would give them a try.

Pros:
They have sales all. the. time. Just wait a few days if you want to order something, and they will most likely offer a sale. But even if you have to pay the regular price, they really aren't terribly priced:

They have free shipping and it is fast! In the several orders that I placed with them, I generally received my oils in less than a week.

They have awesome customer service! I've sent several emails to their aromatherapist and always get a response. Very nice!

They have their own FaceBook group.

All of their oils come with drop reducer orifices. It's the little things, people!

They have 88 (non-organic) single oils and 43 (non-organic) blends. They only offer 19 single oils that are organic.

Cons:

I have a lot of Plant Therapy oils, so I've really given these guys a good try. I feel like their single oils are pretty good over all. I wasn't as impressed with their blends. They only had a small impact on whatever I was using them for. (which was sad because I was trying to find replacement blends for the next company.)

They have very few other products on their website besides essential oils (which is only a con if you are looking for more options).

They are also essential oil rebottlers. They buy their oils, already distilled, and then rebottle, label, and sell them.

5. Young Living
Which essential oil company is best?
Why did I try this company?
I have several friends who use Young Living, and they seemed happy with them. They also show up in a ton of blogs and search results.

Pros:
They are the company that really started the whole essential oil movement in the United States as we know it today, so there is a lot of information out there about them.

They have the longest track record: 20 years.


They have developed most of the testing and standards for the American essential oils industry.



They own their own farms on every continent except Antarctica (understandable, right?)



They test and monitor their entire essential oil process beginning from when they are seeds. They are NOT rebottlers. They grow, harvest, distill, and bottle their own oils.



They have the biggest selection of oils that I've come across: 86 singles and 78 blends.



They have a wholesale membership (like Costco or Sam's Club) that you can purchase to get 24% off of your products. There are no requirements to maintain the membership other than purchasing $50 once each year.



They offer a wide selection of supplements, hygiene products, and household supplies...including kitchen pans. Yeah, I don't really get the pans....



All of their oils come with drop reducer orifices. I thought that was standard for all companies, but now that I know it's not, I'm definitely noting who DOES include these!



Everything they offer is consider more than organic. Because they monitor their oils from the point of them still being seeds, they actually have stricter guidelines that they follow than what the government requires to qualify as organic. However, their oils are not "certified organic." From what I understand, it is because 1) They grow some of their oils on farms in foreign countries. The foreign countries either do not have organic standards or do not have the same standards that we do in America. 2) Some of their oils are gathered from the wild, and it's impossible to prove an organic origin even though they only harvest plants that have been untouched by chemicals. Their quality control process (called "Seed to Seal Standard") is consider to be "more than organic" in spite of the lack of certification.



Cons:

They are expensive. The cost is much higher than some of the other companies:
The shipping is a set amount unless you go over 5 pounds. If the order is just for oils, you'd have to order quite a few to go over that, but any additional products can easily tip the scale, increasing the shipping cost.

They charge tax based on the retail amount of the oils even if you are buying at the wholesale member.

They are a multi-level marketing company. Like the affiliate program with Mountain Rose Herbs, that doesn't really have a bearing on the quality and effectiveness of the oils, but it's worth mentioning. I had a bad experience as a Mary Kay consultant back when we first got married, so I tend to shy away from attaching myself permanently to anything "multi-level marketing" because of that. Again, just being honest. (Which, yeah, that is probably just my own issue, but it still makes me nervous.)

They sometimes run out-of-stock on their oils. This is a pro or con depending upon how you look at it. It's a con in terms of, if you need it and they don't have it, then you are out of luck. It's a pro in that, the reason why they are occasionally out of stock is because their standards are so strict and high that they won't sell anything sub-par. They only sell about 30% of the essential oils that they plant/harvest/bottle, and the rest is used as organic treatments on crops they are growing or disgarded...so I'll let you decide if that goes in the pros or cons category.

***********************


So there you have it. The pros and cons of the four companies that I've tried since the beginning of the year.


Okay, just another note since I know someone is going to comment and ask me about this: Why didn't I try doTERRA? Well...(and this is going to open a big can of worms, I'm sure) I believe that the company has some ethical issues which bother me. They are also oil rebottlers but sell their oils at Young Living prices. If I'm going to buy oils at that price point, I'd rather buy them from a company that monitors them from the point that they are seeds. If I don't care about that, then I'm going to go with a company that is vastly less expensive. Does that make sense? In other words, I consider them to be Mountain Rose Herbs/Plant Therapy level oils with Young Living prices. And I *know* that some of you will disagree with me about that assessment of doTERRA, but that's the much abbreviated version of why I decided not to go that route.



With all of that info out there now, which company did I end up with? There are pros and cons for each of them, and I had quite the list of requirements. Remember, I was looking for the BEST, LEAST EXPENSIVE, MOST EFFECTIVE essential oils. That's a tall order!



After trying all of them, using my family as my test subjects (sorry again, guys!), and researching for hours and hours and hours, where did I end up?



And I promise I'll answer that question really soon! In fact, the next post should answer that question, along with showing you how our chosen essential oil company actually saved us money!

Don't miss the other posts in this series!

Nothing in this post should be taken as medical advice and you should consult your doctor before beginning to use essential oils. This post is purely for entertainment purposes and should be treated as such. Everything is accurate to the best of my knowledge, but please do your own research!!

Sunday, May 18, 2014

Essential Oils: To Ingest or Not to Ingest? (and how I ended up picking my method)

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote a long post about the three schools of thought as it pertains to essential oils. I had a ton of comments on the blog and on FaceBook asking for more info, so I'll just keep writing about what I've learned until you all tell me to stop. :)

(If you haven't read the previous post outlining the schools of thought, this would be a good time to do that so that this post makes sense. Don't worry! I'll wait right here for you!)

Once I realized that there were three schools of thought, that left me with the big question:

Which School of Thought should I Follow?
or more specifically
How do I Feel about Ingesting Essential Oils and Using Them Neat?

I quickly decided that I was okay with doing more than just inhaling oils, so I was able to cross the German School of Thought off of my list. That left just the British and French schools to decide between. And boy, those two schools couldn't be more different. The British school says that inhaling and topical application with diluted oils is the only safe way to go. The French school says that inhaling, topical application (often with "neat" or undiluted oils), and ingesting is the way to go. Ingesting is a big point of contention between the two sides.

I was SO frustrated. The opinions were polar opposite and both sides have research and experts to back up what they think.

So which school of thought did I decide to go with? Well...both actually.

Over the last few months, I've tried both methods and oils from four different companies. Today, we are just going to look at how I chose my method without discussing the actual brands of oils that I tried. We will save that for another post. The best way to explain how I arrived at which method to use is just to outline how I've used the essential oils over the last few months.

Ready? Here we go!

Toward the end of January, after a lot of research, I finally ordered an essential oil kit from a company (a French school based company). I wanted to give it a good try, so I ordered a large enough selection of oils to really get my feet wet. My kit contained a diffuser, 11 oils, and a few extra samples of various other things. I bought a small handbook to tell me how to use them, and some coconut oil for application. I was totally overwhelmed at first, but quickly found a wonderful support group with people who were willing to help me as questions came up.

So far, so good. Now I just needed something good to try these things on.

In late January, I fell and broke my leg. I so wish I could blame it on ice, but nope! I just tripped as I was walking down the stairs and broke my fibula. Have you ever broken a bone? It hurts! Luckily, I was given Percoset for the pain. It worked pretty well, but it wasn't quite enough to completely zap the pain, although it totally zapped my energy. Then, about a week or so after the break, I decided that I must be better, and stopped taking it. Yeah, don't do that. The pain gets in front of you and it's hard to catch back up. Apparently, they prescribe those drugs for a very good reason. On an impulse, I started rubbing an oil, neat (or undiluted), directly over the spot that was broken. It was enough to take the edge off while I was waiting for the Percoset to catch back up. Thank goodness, because it hurt SO much!

But how much of that was just the placebo effect? Yeah, still not convinced essential oils work. I was probably making it up in my head. I was high on Percoset after all.

In February, I started to feel like my immune system was going to dip. I used the oils by inhalation and topically. I was following the French school's suggestions except for ingesting the oils because I wasn't comfortable with that just yet. Everything else, though, was as they suggested. Unbelievably, I was able to maintain my wellness level! Dang! That’s cool, I thought. That is NOT what generally happens with my very American lifestyle.

Can someone have the placebo effect happen when trying to maintain wellness? That seems like it would be harder to do. Need to keep experimenting...

In late February/March, I felt like my immune system was getting wobbly again. This time, I had to work a little harder to keep it up, but I was still able to keep my wellness level where I needed it to be.

Maybe this does work? Crazy!

Meanwhile, in February/March, I started buying oils from a different company. I loved the oils that I had, but I thought that I could find them cheaper. I'm ever on the hunt to save my family money, so I bought a selection of oils that were about 1/4 of the cost of the first batch that I bought. These oils and the company associated with them are from the British School, so I continued to use inhalation and topical application but not ingestion as I continued to do research. I also started following the British school of thought groups more closely and joined this company's FaceBook page. The more I read, the more I learned about how they suggested essential oils should be used to be safe. I ended up changing the way I used the oils to be even more conservative in my approach as promoted by the British school. Their safety guidelines had me a little worried, so I wanted to make sure that I was following them.

So now I was in a group that focused on the French school, and a couple of groups that focused on the British school. For good measure, I was routinely posting any questions that I had in both the British and French groups to compare answers and techniques. And as expected, the answers were totally different.

My frustration with essential oils was mounting. Who is right? What is safe? What is effective? Must do more research.

About this time, my hubby’s immune system needed some attention. The poor guy ended up being my guinea pig. (Sorry, Babe!) I was still using the French school approach (minus the ingestion) when we started looking at oils to support his wellness. With their methods, we were right on top of it, and he was getting awesome immune support. I was delighted to see that the essential oils were working for him as well! Unfortunately, three days into it, I read that what I was doing wasn't the safest approach, and that I needed to highly dilute all of the oils. So based on suggestions from the FaceBook group for the new company that I was trying, I completely changed what I was doing without telling Sean. I knew he wasn't going to notice, so I figured that this would be an excellent way to see which approach worked better.

Uh oh.

It so did not work. His immune system immediately nose-dived, and Sean ended up having another heart episode as he does whenever he gets really ill (We’ve seen a cardiologist. There is no “fix” for it. It’s just something he lives with. That’s why wellness is super important for him.) He was out for days. I should add that as I was adjusting my approach to essential oils, I asked a lot of questions in the British school based group and also emailed directly with their aromatherapist who was about two months away from complete certification. When Sean had his heart episode, I went back to the group and the aromatherapist to find out what I did wrong. I emailed back and forth with her, trying to understand where I went wrong. Please note that in the following emails, I have removed all brand names and identifying oil names since this is a post about schools of thought and methods of application. We will talk brands in another post! I just want you to understand the research and background first.

"When I first started, I was following the French school and rubbing the following on his chest: First coconut oil, and then lemon, peppermint, and lavender.I have no idea what that dilution would end up being, but it worked! I also put Thieves/Germ Fighter in the diffuser. Coconut Oil on the bottoms of his feet with Thieves/Germ Fighter. And a calming oil on his wrists. Those were all from [the first company] that I bought oils from. 
Then my order came in from [your company], and I switched to the following: I mixed Peppermint, a respiratory supporting oil, Ravensara, and Lavender with Sunflower Oil at a 10% dilution in a roller ball. I was also diffusing Thieves/Germ Fighter and Lemon at the same time, and had him rub Thieves/Germ Fighter over a light layer of coconut oil on the bottoms of his feet. 
I used the [French school's method] for about 2-3 days, and we were maintaining his wellness level! Then we switched to [the British method] and the 10% dilution on a Sunday evening. On Tuesday morning he was passed out on the bathroom floor.
Passing out is status quo for my hubby when he is very sick. I wasn't surprised that he passed out because his heart was stressed. However, we were right on top of it, supporting his natural systems, and it looked like we were going to skate through....but then we didn't. :(
Also, just as an extra note, while I switched my hubby over to [the diluted oils and British school,] I continued to use them myself as [the French school] suggested. I put Thieves/Germ Fighter on the bottom of my feet with a carrier, lavender behind my ears and at my temples neat, and calming oil on my wrists neat. And I also breathed in the diffused Thieves/Germ Fighter as well.
I was able to support my immune system, but my hubby went downhill.”
She forwarded my email on to their company expert, and replied with this (wording has been adjusted because her reply was not FDA compliant. The meaning is intact though):

"I just heard back from our expert and there are a couple things they recommend.  
1. Do not change the method in the middle of [something]. [These situations] are really hard because they continue to mutate and change all the time. What is working one time and with one person, most likely won't work as well the next time and with the next person.  
2. The best way to fight something like that is topical inhalation. That means applying to the chest, back of neck and bottom of the feet which it sounds like you were doing. 
3. The dilution is up to you. If you are only using these oils [only a few times a year] and not on a regular basis, use a higher dilution. Especially if you are using the oils on the bottom of your feet. I always recommend diluting oils but if you are only using these oils a couple times a year, then make them a stronger dilution. Just make sure that you are diluting 'hot' oils enough. That will be the main concern here that you don't burn your skin when applying topically.  
So to clarify, you don't have to use a 10% dilution if you are only using for a few days (…) a couple times a year. You can use a higher dilution if that [works[] faster. Also find what works (…) and stick with it. The oils you are using will generally be the best oils but you might need more [of one oil] one time and more Lemon the next time depending on the [situation]."

It kind of makes sense that I shouldn't have switched in the middle of intensely focusing on Sean’s support, but I was clearly using the oils they would have suggested, and even though they said to up the concentration, they still suggested that I keep the oils pretty diluted. Okay. So at this point, the French school provided wonderful wellness support, and the British school should do the same if I increase the concentration a little bit.

This must have been a fluke that it didn't work. Other than upping the concentration, I did everything correctly. I obviously need to try this method again.

I'm super cautious, and I really want to do the best, safest thing for my family. So in spite of the fact that it didn't work the first time I tried it, I decided to fully commit to the British school and pretty much wrote off the original company I tried. I decided that their approach must not be safe and the new group must be safe...even though it didn't work.

(Sheesh, I hope you all are following this. It's kind of convoluted!) 

And then everything went down hill.

In March our kids started preschool and began to bring home every germ that they could possibly find. They were sick constantly, and they managed to personally share with me everything they had as well. The stomach flu, colds, fevers, etc. It was awful, but also status quo for my little preemies.
Let’s just be honest here. Everyone gets sick, and I expect nothing less, BUT I was really hoping for at least a little immune support.

But it really got bad in April. In April, my immune system bottomed out. When I say bottomed out, what I really mean is that it completely crashed. I used all of the suggestions that the British school and less expensive essential oil company gave me. I upped the concentration, I rubbed oils everywhere, I diffused them next to my head, I slept extra, yet I kept getting worse. My voice disappeared, my throat was sore, and then my chest started to hurt. And still, it was getting worse. Wellness? Immune support? None of it even existed at that point.

Why didn't my oils work?

So I went to the Minute Clinic, was diagnosed with bronchitis, and got antibiotics, inhalers and a sore throat gargle. It took 2-3 weeks to recover, and I spent a good part of that being unable to talk above a whisper.

The modern meds worked, and I got better (yay!), but I still wanted to figure out how to support the immune system that my body was equipped with. I wasn’t looking for a cure all. I just wanted to do everything I could to stay WELL in the first place. I was really hoping that essential oils would give our family the extra boost that we obviously so desperately needed.

And then a week later, I had a second cold. At this point, it was the middle of April. I'd already been down for weeks. Within a few days, I could tell that I was in bad shape again. Another trip to the Minute Clinic had them telling me that bronchitis was back, and I most likely had asthma since the colds kept returning (I also had bronchitis six months earlier in October). They sent me to my primary care doctor. My doctor ran numerous tests and said I had adult onset asthma, and a very severe case of bronchitis that was bordering on pneumonia.

What?!?! But I'm following the essential oil immune supporting recommendations to the letter!

At this point, my hubby and I also had this conversation:

Sean: "Hey Bec? Do you consider yourself a sickly person?" 
Me *in denial*: "No, I'm not a sickly person!"

Again, I had done exactly as I was told to do by the British school. Instead, I found myself back on meds, trying to recover from my second round of bronchitis. I think I filled seven prescriptions that week. Not a joke. Essential oils and their wellness supporting capabilities? Now that was a joke.

Guess what happened after that?

(Can I just add here….it is much easier to maintain wellness from the get go, then to do this immune system yo-yoing thing I had going on. It is a fight to ever get back to a position of wellness once you’ve let yourself nosedive.)


Three days after finishing my antibiotics, I came down with a third cold. It started on a Friday night. By Saturday afternoon, I knew bronchitis would set in within a day or so. I was playing ring-around-the-rosie and unless I made a life change, I couldn’t see myself getting to leave the playground…like ever.

Me: "Babe...I think I'm a sickly person." (and yes, I may have been crying tears of frustration.)

So I went back to the very first essential oil company I tried in January and said, "What do I do? You tell me exactly what to do to support my immune system, and I'll do it. I'm desperate. It’s been 5 weeks, my immune system is in the tank, and I'm exhausted. I've been using the oils per the British school, and they clearly are doing nothing to support my body."

They gave me their suggestions, and I dusted off the remainder of the first oils that I bought. I started rubbing, diffusing, and ingesting the oils. I was so desperate to stabilize my immune system and find that happy wellness plateau. The British school hadn't worked at all. Would the French school be any different? Because I was done and about two minutes from giving up on essential oils altogether.

Five days.

Once I started actually using oils that worked WITH my body’s natural systems, it took three days to start feeling in balance. Within five days, I felt...well, I felt great!

Five days.

And the expensive oils that I thought I couldn't afford? Well, I actually kept a very detailed list of exactly what and how much I used of each oil to support my body’s natural healthy systems. I have a paper with the cost calculated down to the penny. I ended up saving money. True story.

But you'll have to wait for another post for the price breakdown. This one is getting too long.

All that to say, I've tried the British School of Thought and I've tried the French School of Thought. I think the British school is far too conservative in their approach. Using oils is great, but if they don't actually do anything to support our major systems, then it's just a waste of time and money. I think the French School can often be too liberal. No need to ingest large amounts and waste the oils! But ingesting on occasion, keeping our wellness level in tip-top shape, and saving tons of money is worth it in my opinion. I think the key is balance.

Since then, we've used the oils and the French approach for our entire family. I wanted to make sure that it wasn't a total fluke, and that they really would provide support for all six of us. It sounds crazy to say, but they really work!

Alrighty. This post is way too long, but I'm going to leave it as is anyway. In the next couple of weeks, I'll post about the four essential oil companies that I've researched and tried, and how we've actually saved money (what?!) with the particular essential oil company that we decided to go with.

Meanwhile, I'm sold on the French approach, and will happily ingest essential oils if it helps keep my body in a happy place!

What do you think? British School or French School? I know this is a touchy subject for many, so let's keep the comments polite!

Don't miss the other posts in this series!


Disclaimer: I am not an aromatherapist, and I have no formal essential oil training. This post (and all other posts about essential oils) should never take the place or be considered a substitution for a doctor's advice. Please, do your own research and ask your own questions!
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...